Thomas The Tank Engine vs Lightning Mcqueen

1 : Anonymous2021/03/07 16:53 ID: lzuja8

Who would win?

2 : Anonymous2021/03/07 17:37 ID: gq45yf1

Thomas crushes him on a train track due to being a train. Mcqueen can't even fight so I don't know what you expected.

ID: gq4kto9

But Thomas is restricted to the track. McQueen has been seen to be able to go off-road, so he has the advantage

ID: gq4xa4e

McQueen's only chance is if Thomas is pulling some "troublesome trucks" that might cause him to de-rail, and thereby leave him vulnerable.

3 : Anonymous2021/03/07 17:44 ID: gq46ucp

Lightning Mcqueen rams into Thomas’ side and is completely wrecked whereas Thomas just needs some repairs.

A train isn’t going to lose to a race-car lol

4 : Anonymous2021/03/07 19:42 ID: gq4o59u

Well, Thomas has a massive size, weight and strength advantage, but he's limited to being on the tracks, while McQueen is faster and much more mobile. That said, McQueen will have to go on the tracks if he wants to win, and when he does Thomas crushes him. Only way I see McQueen winning is through a lucky shot, ramming him and puncturing Thomas's boiler or something. Even then, he's going to get seriously hurt.

Nice prompt, but Thomas wins 9/10.

ID: gq4stxb

Yeah to be fair if he ruptured Thomas' boiler, he would die in the explosion afterwards. Turns out suicide is the best option in this case

5 : Anonymous2021/03/07 18:30 ID: gq4dl5w

Lightning wouldn’t really be capable of doing much to him he only has a speed advantage

6 : Anonymous2021/03/07 21:43 ID: gq55is7

In a race or time trial, McQueen by a country mile unless it was a marathon with no pit stops. And even then he could still win by a tongue 😉

7 : Anonymous2021/03/08 00:05 ID: gq5n3r0

How much prep time? If they can prep, Lightning can just get Mater's spy friends to loan him some explosives, so he can blow up a bridge so Thomas ends up falling into a river and drowning or into a canyon.

8 : Anonymous2021/03/08 00:48 ID: gq5rqpe

Thomas is relegated to the tracks and doesn't have much autonomy outside of them. He also doesn't have much maneuverability. However, he does have the advantage of being a train, albeit a small one. McQueen's going to get wrecked if he comes into direct contact with him, whether he collides with Thomas or Thomas collides with him. However, the cars in the Cars series have significantly more autonomy than the trains on the Island of Sodor. McQueen can maneuver pretty freely without coming into contact with Thomas, and he has the capacity to set up elaborate traps and use weapons. These particular cars are much closer to humans than these particular trains are (remember all the infrastructure and technology that the characters are able to use in the Cars series, particularly in Cars 2). If it's Lightning McQueen at a later point in his arc, he should be able to set up a trap for Thomas that he won't be able to avoid. If it's early in the first movie, however, McQueen will probably be overconfident in his own abilities and end up losing as he tries to take on Thomas head-on.

9 : Anonymous2021/03/08 08:51 ID: gq6y6yu

Thomas wins. Lightning keeps on hitting Thomas but Thomas tanks it ez. This would result in Lightning taking unnecessary damage from his first attack. Thomas cant attack unless of course ya boi Lightning on the track so either stalemate or Thomas really does tank it.

10 : Anonymous2021/03/08 11:48 ID: gq78wpa

Most likely mcqueen because he can fly and has missiles plus thomas is restricted to the tracks

11 : Anonymous2021/03/08 12:47 ID: gq7diqd

Who would win a race?

Or who would win in making deliveries?

Our do you mean a fight?


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x