AMD is trying to sell me an RX580 for $685

1 : Anonymous2021/11/03 20:52 ID: qm3yax

Long story short, my beloved R9 390X died and I sent it back to AMD. It was out of warranty but, given the current state of GPU availability, I figured what the hell, let's see what it costs to have it repaired. Their response came back a couple days ago; it can't be repaired but they'll sell me a ROG-STRIX-RX580-8G-GAMING for $685.

I'm really not sure what to think, here. I'm not really up on the latest graphics cards. I know the market is crazy right now. A post on a different sub asking if this was a good deal yielded many responses to the tune of "fuck no," "jesus no," "definitely not," and the like. Responders also pointed out that the card in question is a few years old and that 3060s are going on eBay for about that price.

I've never sent a graphics card into the manufacturer before. Is this kind of offer pretty typical?

I just miss my R9 390X. I was perfectly happy with it before it went kaput. Had it five years and probably would've been content to use it for another five.

Edit: some people questioning the validity of this. When I get home from work I'll post some screenshots.

Edit2: Okay, time to come clean, here, a little bit. The RMA was actually through ASUS, not AMD. I'll admit I had a major brainfart, here. When I was thinking about which subreddit to post on for feedback, my brain just went straight to "well, it's an AMD card, let's post on the AMD sub." But, of course, the card was actually made by ASUS and so that's who I went through for the return. I feel like a real bonehead. Just for shits and gigs and to prove I'm not totally full of crap, though, I'll post the clarifying screenshots from ASUS support that I promised earlier:

Edit3: I just want to add that I was definitely NOT trying to besmirch anyone's name, here. I was honestly just looking for feedback. I loved my R9 390X and was super bummed when it died, and not just because of the current cost of GPUs. It was a great card. I also want to say that I was NOT just fishing for sympathy, as some people have claimed. I sent the card in because it was only $30 for the two-way shipping label and I was honestly hoping it could be repaired for a decent price. Some here have said that was naive, that companies simply don't do out-of-warranty repairs. Well, I don't know anything about that. Like I said, I loved my R9 390X and was truly hoping it could be brought back to life.

2 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:03 ID: hj771wf

Never heard of a manufacturer doing that, but I've never sent in a card out of warranty. You could do better for $700.

Used you can get a used 1080ti for $600-$700 right now,

New you could get a brand new 6600 xt for $700 even at scalper prices.

ID: hj7caao

If you live near a microcenter and are willing to bide your time a little, you can get a 6600 XT for $500.

ID: hj7j0iv

Right, $700 is even a stretch for a 6600 xt, OP could do better.

ID: hj7hs4l

Different market but Canon offers an extra discount on refurbished camera products if you have a broken Canon camera out of warranty.

3 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:18 ID: hj79czj

AMD selling directly? Isnt it someone else handling stuff like that for them?

ID: hj7ao3z

Selling an ASUS card too.

ID: hj7pdlo

Please see my edit to my OP. I made a big goof and was thinking my return was through AMD when it was actually through ASUS. I apologize for the misinformation and appreciate your input, nevertheless.

ID: hj7aeez

It was an official RMA response from AMD.

Edit: Not true! The return was through ASUS! Sorry, everybody!

ID: hj7k2j3

Could you include a screenshot in your post?

ID: hj7mmw6

Can you post it here please - I think everyone is curious about this, as this would be a 1st ever for AMD to do that. Especially a card that isn't even made any more.

ID: hj7cyjz

Hey official AMD here! You wana buy Radeon RX 6800 for 8000 €$?

4 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:28 ID: hj7axgp

Why would AMD be offering to sell you an Asus card? Are you sure you're dealing with AMD and not a 3rd party repair shop?

ID: hj7bry0

It seems quite unusual.

ID: hj7pmtq

Please see my edit to my OP. I made a big goof and was thinking my return was through AMD when it was actually through ASUS. I apologize for the misinformation and appreciate your input, nevertheless.

5 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:07 ID: hj77ro5

That sounds like a scam. This is AMD directly or a local company in charge of support?

ID: hj7gz2g

AMD doesn't do warranty repairs direct. It's always a contracted repair vendor.

6 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:07 ID: hj77mwo

You can buy a used 580 off of eBay for less than $400...

ID: hj7bsev

wow really? i have an rx580 4gb msi armor. ill take that 400 bucks off your hands if you want xd

ID: hj7bz36

I looked at eBay to see how much the used RX 570 4GBs were going for. They were all at around $250.

I bought mine in mid-2019 for about $80.

7 : Anonymous2021/11/03 22:01 ID: hj7fw2n

I call BS.

R9 390X is way EOL and out of warranty. Also was this even a refrence R9 390x? Why would you hit up AMD for a warranty when (since you didn't indicate) it maybe a AIB card (lack of details calls into question the validity). You don't just blindly send a card into be RMA'd, you have to request an RMA first and then they provide instruction if you are even eligible, and how/were to send the card. With it being a EOL/Out of warranty they would have rejected the request from the start, as it would be a complete waste of time and resources for all parties involved. AMD is not going to try and sell you a 3rd party AIB that is 3 generations old. If anything if they were to "offer" to you directly it would be a current generation reference card. There is nothing in it for them to offer a very old 3rd party card as why would they even have 3rd party AIB cards in stock if they don't even have refrence cards of that generation in stock? They will want their latest product to be what is out there and being sent out.
ID: hj7pm37

Please see my edit to my OP. I made a big goof and was thinking my return was through AMD when it was actually through ASUS. The RMA is legit, however. See my screenshots for more info. I apologize for the misinformation and appreciate your input, nevertheless.

8 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:22 ID: hj79xqp

scam radar is tingling.

How did your GPU die, if you have any insight there?

9 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:26 ID: hj7aisw

Sounds like tech support is trying to pawn off his old graphics card on OP. Next thing you know, they'll ask you to pay in Amazon gift cards.

ID: hj7mr1x

PayPal F&F lol

10 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:48 ID: hj7dv2b

That not inline with what they would or could do.

Somethings a bit off here. This sounds like a personal transaction (I wouldn’t know any RMA outfit to physically have a card and try to sell it to you for 2 times it’s MSRP). Even with the custom fans it maybe 400, but nearly 700 dollars for, what I can only assume is a used card as AMD discontinued the production of that line.

Call AMD’s compliance line and report this and ask what the policy is regarding the resale of RMA used and discontinued cards. Call the compliance department directly.

11 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:52 ID: hj7egv2

RMA department doesn't sell cards as far as I know, they generally will tell you it can't be fixed and will offer to recycle it or send it back to you at your expense.

12 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:04 ID: hj776al

Personnaly, I would not buy an RX 580 for $685, not only because it is too expensive, but because it is obsolete. Even with the current shortages, you could get a more modern graphic card for this price, like an RX 6600

13 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:18 ID: hj79f2t

This is officially from AMD and not some 3rd party?

ID: hj79s8k

Yes, official AMD RMA response.

Edit: Incorrect! I mistakenly said the return was through AMD but it was actually through ASUS! D'oh! Sorry, everybody!

ID: hj7biup


Any insight?

ID: hj7mtbf

Post it here please - everyone is curious to see this.

14 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:09 ID: hj77xw2

Get screen shots of other reputable retailers prices and see if they'll beat those. In your situation it can't hurt to haggle.

15 : Anonymous2021/11/03 22:23 ID: hj7j01l

This looks like a scam. Be exceptionally careful.

For 685$ you can do a whole lot better. A 6600XT would be a much better deal at that price.

16 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:56 ID: hj7f4kc

Why would you send a dead GPU back to AMD, knowing it has no warranty?

What were you trying to accomplish? Looking for sympathy? A story to post on reddit and get a free GPU?

I don't get these threads really.

ID: hj7hbcs

Repair centers will repair cards out of warranty for a fee. You ship it to them to get a quote for the repair.

ID: hj7hx37

Tell me a single time an OEM actually repaired a card and sent it back?

EVGA may be the only retailer doing it, and even then, it's rare.

This dude is just looking for sympathy for nothing.

17 : Anonymous2021/11/03 22:36 ID: hj7ktp0

What the hell?

Mind, Coughing up the the name of the customer service rep and every trace of contact they've had with you.

Because I can not believe this isn't a scam regardless of being directly from AMD.

18 : Anonymous2021/11/03 22:40 ID: hj7lh2z

I didn’t realize how fucked the market really is, I got a Red Devil 5700xt for $450 on launch and thought that was pricy damn

19 : Anonymous2021/11/03 23:12 ID: hj7ptpe

I'm surprised they let you send in for RMA for out of warranty.

20 : Anonymous2021/11/03 23:12 ID: hj7py64

Damn. That's rough. But title needs to be changed!

ID: hj7qc1b

Would if I could! Again, I apologize for the misinformation! I was definitely not trying to besmirch AMD's name or anything. I loved, loved, loved my R9 390X and was super bummed when it died.

21 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:07 ID: hj77o8x

wow! strange that AMD would do that...

22 : Anonymous2021/11/03 20:57 ID: hj763tz

I think I paid $250-300 for mine brand new in 2018. They are nice cards but I wouldn't pay $700 for one.

23 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:00 ID: hj76m63

Yes the price they’d offer definitely crazy, in case you sure it died then try to repair on local PC store instead of the manufacturer. Idk how often a company offer other product when they did a repairing.

In case you okay with other GPU, try to look at used market on Ebay or smt like that. Even GPU market is on craze, there is no way such expensive as that.

ID: hj7ali0

Your local PC store repairs graphic cards?

24 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:23 ID: hj7a4nq

Message me i have a 4Gb and 8Gb 580. i would be willing to part with if your in need.

25 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:27 ID: hj7aqvf

Ill sell my Rx580 8g for 400 . Lol

26 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:46 ID: hj7dmpw

I've never sent in a GPU out of warranty, but that price for a 580 is insane. Obviously not something you should consider.

If I had that 390X, I'd take a look at what broke on the card with a multimeter. If it looks like it's just a small board component that broke, you could sell the card for maybe $30-60 on ebay for someone else to fix or use for parts.

27 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:51 ID: hj7eaue

I paid, literally, a quarter of that for that card in 2019.

What a scam.

28 : Anonymous2021/11/03 21:59 ID: hj7fhv9

I bought a rx580 4gb sapphire nitro+ for €100 2 weeks ago. That offer is a joke.


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x